utka's review of Medaka Kuroiwa Is Impervious To My Charms

utka's avatar
utka

i thought i would review the manga i read and give my opinions on them since to help get through my long list of plan to read and i wanted to see what others thought of the manga i read, also please give critiques of the review like writing, structure and topics covered, since i do want to make this a regular thing. Synopsis: Mona Kawai is the epitome of charm—adored by everyone at school and fully aware of her stunning appeal. However, her confidence is shaken when Medaka Kuroiwa, the only boy seemingly unaffected by her beauty, remains indifferent. Determined to win his attention, Mona pulls out all the stops, but nothing works. What she doesn't know is that Kuroiwa is in training to become a monk, strictly avoiding worldly temptations. As Mona tries harder to seduce him, she begins to discover unexpected feelings of her own, setting the stage for a unique and comical romance. how much i have read: 10 chapters found it on some guys 3x3 and thought i would give it a read Art: 6/10 the art for this manga is not the best and not the worst, the characters are nice to look at but they dont stand out in any way. if you put them in a room with a bunch of other characters with the same basic style it would be very hard to spot them. one thing i did like about the art was how, every time mona did something cute or medaka ignored her, you could see her fans reacting in the background thought that was a cool thing. Plot: 5/10 the premise isnt really that interesting to me. the mc is kinda like a tsundere, but instead of snapping or yelling, he just avoids everything. the whole "i must avoid worldly desires" thing feels like its supposed to be funny, but it didnt land for me. Character: 5/10 i feel like they are just 2D drawings with no real substance. the manga just didnt give me any reason to feel attached/like them. one is a super popular girl who everyone loves and adores and the other is the son of a monk who came to live in the city for the first time and is a loner. i feel like these tropes are fairly basic and nothing was really done to make them interesting Enjoyment: 4/10 not much to talk about in this department didnt really enjoy reading this, it just felt like another basic romance manga with not much substance Final rating and thoughts: 5/10 (dropped) its a pretty basic romance manga in my eyes but i dont think ill be continuing especially after finding out its almost 200 chapter long and still on going what are your guys thoughts on this manga have you read it or do you plan to read it

Comments

wibu's avatar
wibu

It's dime a dozen of space cadet girl teasing shy boy troupe 🤷

Reply
    SturdyCock's avatar
    SturdyCock

    Good review. I skimmed 2-3 chapters and then just never touched it again it didn't manage to draw me in

    Reply
      BBGF's avatar
      BBGF

      I read like 150 chapters or smth, and the romance didn't progress at all, and the author kept introducing new crushes that fell in love with Medaka, when all he said was like, "Hi. Nice weather today, huh," or something like that. Good thing you dropped it, twin🥳🥳🥳

      Reply
      1 Reply
        Daddy__Long__Legs's avatar
        Daddy__Long__Legs

        After the whole swimsuit arc and him gaining a third crush, it fell

        Reply
        1 Reply
          yves's avatar
          yves

          I’m here for utkas reviews 🙏

          Reply
          1 Reply
            LUCA's avatar
            LUCA

            i aint reading allat

            Reply
            2 Replies
              Jokerpersona's avatar
              Jokerpersona

              It had potential then it just became your typical harem romance

              Reply
              1 Reply

                Rules

                1. Be Respectful

                Treat all members with respect. Personal attacks, harassment, hate speech, or discrimination of any kind will not be tolerated.

                Respect different opinions and viewpoints. Healthy debates are encouraged, but always maintain civility.

                2. Stay On-Topic

                Ensure your posts and comments are relevant to the manga being discussed.

                Avoid spamming or posting unrelated content.

                3. No Spoilers Without Warning

                Clearly label any posts or comments that contain spoilers. Use the appropriate spoiler tags and warnings.

                Be considerate of others who may not be up-to-date with the latest chapters

                4. No Advertising or Self-Promotion

                Do not use the discussion page for advertising or promoting other websites, products, or services.

                Self-promotion, including links to personal blogs or social media, is not allowed.

                5. Respect Privacy

                Do not share personal information, either your own or others'.

                Avoid posting content that violates someone else's privacy.

                6. Report Inappropriate Content

                If you come across any content that violates these rules, please report it to the moderators.

                Do not engage with rule-breakers; instead, let the moderators handle the situation.